Wood, bamboo and aluminum peels: how the materials differ
Which materials do pizza peels come in?
Mostly wood and metal. One oven maker also sells a bamboo peel. Wikipedia says peels are usually made of wood, and that the flat part can instead be sheet metal attached to a wooden handle.1
Pictures of real pizza making show both. Wikipedia's pizza article has a photo of an unbaked pizza on a metal peel and another of a pizza coming out on a wooden one.2 Neither material is wrong. They suit different jobs.
How does wood behave with heat?
Wood stays cooler. Wikipedia lists that as wood's advantage. Metal can get hot enough to burn a user's hands, and wood doesn't.1
That's a point about hands, though. It doesn't mean a wooden peel is happy sitting in a very hot oven. If you're unsure how much heat your peel can take, check the maker's notes for it.
What about metal?
Wikipedia says the flat part can be sheet metal.1 One oven maker describes its classic peel as lightweight aluminum.3 Light matters when you're holding a loaded peel out at arm's length.
The same maker says an anodised finish makes its perforated aluminum peel non-stick.3 That's the maker's claim for that peel, not for aluminum peels in general or for the classic peel. "Anodised" means the metal has had a surface treatment, so look at what your own peel's maker says.
Wikipedia says metal can become hot enough to burn hands.1 If you slide a metal peel into a hot oven, follow your own product's manual on gloves and other protection.
Where does bamboo fit?
One maker says it chose bamboo designed to be moisture resistant, to help stop dough sticking during launch.3 It calls that peel great for stretching and launching.3
That's a maker describing its own product, so take it as a description, not a test result.
Is there a simple way to compare them?
Here's a plain comparison of what the sources say. It isn't a ranking.
| Material | What a source says | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Wood | Doesn't become hot enough to burn hands the way metal can | 1 |
| Sheet metal | Can be used for the flat part, attached to a wooden handle | 1 |
| Aluminum | Described by one maker as lightweight | 3 |
| Bamboo | Described by one maker as moisture resistant | 3 |
Does one material work for everything?
Probably not. The oven maker quoted above recommends two peels: a perforated one for launching and retrieving, and a small turning peel.3 That idea has its own page, on using two peels.
It also says its bamboo peel is great for launching, though it would recommend metal for retrieval.3 So the maker itself uses more than one material for different tasks.
What should I check before I decide?
Read the manual for your oven. It may say which peel it expects you to use and how to handle it in the heat. Then think about the job: building and launching, or turning and taking out.
Sticking is a separate matter. It depends on moisture, flour and timing as well as the material. The sticking page goes through them.
Notes and sources
- Peel (tool), Wikipedia
- Pizza, Wikipedia
- How to Pick the Right Pizza Peel, Ooni Europe